Alice goffmans book on fugitive life in philly under attack. Yes, it is true that one generally needs to speak to the members of the key audience for a product or service. The ethics of ethnography, and alice goffmans ethnography. Fugitive life in an american city, she interviews george taylor, father of linda, who is one of the central characters, and. Ethnography, inequality, social interaction and social psychology, race and ethnicity, punishment. Ethnography as methodology in alice goffman s on the run. Controversy over alice goffman leads pomona students to say. The trials of alice goffman her first book, on the run about the lives of young black men in west philadelphia has fueled a fight within sociology over who gets to speak for whom. In an overflowing room at the american sociological association meetings in san francisco last week, alice goffman, assistant professor of sociology at the university of wisconsin, madison and daughter of the late erving goffman, faced her critics and supporters as they discussed her new book. Bret hartmanted not too long ago, you may recall, the sociologist alice goffmans ethnography of a workingclass, black philadelphia neighborhood, on the run. Alice goffman s on the run has become one of the most controversial books published in sociology in many years. Alice goffmans implausible ethnography the chronicle of.
Journalists are peeved that goffman followed social science protocols and not journalistic ones. Some of goffmans supporters maintained that her sixyear embed with innercity philadelphia youths pushed. Sep 15, 2016 alice goffmans implausable ethnography. The recent controversy surrounding ethnography, sparked by the publication of alice goffmans book on the run, is the latest in a longstanding debate about the morals and ethics of ethnographic research. Many people have criticized alice goffman s ethnography on the run. Bret hartmanted not too long ago, you may recall, the sociologist alice goffman s ethnography of a workingclass, black philadelphia neighborhood, on the run. The book is a good look into how heavy policing affects all aspects of individual and community life. What we would have is an undivided, interstitial field of anthropology.
Notes on alice goffmans on the run find, read and cite all the research you need on researchgate. Goffman also hit the scene at a time of revived interest in ethnography. Fugitive life in an american city, the sociologist alice goffman recounts a heartwrenching story. Lots has been written about alice goffmans on the run. Alice goffman s denial of murder conspiracy raises even more questions. Douglas hartmann on ethnography in light of goffman give. Controversy over alice goffman leads pomona students to say her. Goffman language learning, stigma, and protecting a potentially spoiled identity. While most ethnographic projects are completed over a year and a half. Goffmans ethnography is sharply observed, capturing the rhythms and tensions of a hyperpoliced black neighborhood. His article for the chronicle of higher education, alice goffman s implausible ethnography, criticizes goffman as a sociologist, as a journalist, and even as the teller of a plausible story. Fugitive life in an american city, is an ethnographic study of a black neighborhood in philadelphia where, according to goffman s research.
Her ted talk, which was often interrupted by applause, has had nearly 700,000 views. Some thoughts on goffmans on the run august 8, 2014 the art of the state, the law at every level sara mayeux after initially receiving mostly adulatory press which it continues to receive, including a malcolm gladwell essay in the current new yorker, the sociologist alice goffmans urban ethnography on the run. A 34yearold untenured professor of sociology at the university of wisconsin, madison, goffman had just begun a year of leave at the institute for advanced study in princeton, which she hoped she might use to escape her critics and get back to work. Jun 11, 2015 alice goffmans book on fugitive life in philly under attack critics say penn alums depiction of police routinely requesting visitor info from hospitals is the stuff of urban legend. Controversy over alice goffmans book lives on, with students at pomona. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. In the summer of 2007, her friend chuck taylor is shot in the head outside a chinese takeout restaurant in philadelphia and rushed to the hospital, the apparent victim of an ongoing gang rivalry. Pdf on sep 15, 2016, john van maanen and others published the making of a classic ethnography.
The situation is a product of the united states skyrocketing incarceration ratesin the poor undereducated black neighborhood goffman studies, something like 10% of the young men are incarcerated at any one time. Fugitive life in an american city has started also to receive more negative attention. As a piece of social science it is refreshingly and gloriously readable how. But not everybody was so impressed by goffman s harrowing account of the six years she spent. Her moving account of several young black men and their legal entanglements has raised questions about how whites represent blacks in their research, what obligations researchers have to avoid illegal activities of their own, and, most importantly, about the character of truth in. Alice goffmans on the run is the best treatment i know of the wretched underside. With rich ethnographic detail, alice goffman reveals the emotional arc of deceptively complex young lives that are criminalized daily in one black neighborhood in philadelphia.
Based on six years spent in a philadelphia neighborhood, goffman details the myriad ways in which young. Why you should listen as an undergraduate studying sociology at the university of pennsylvania, alice goffman was inspired to write her senior thesis about the lives of the young people living. The first set of criticisms i noticed were from people who claimed that she misrepresented black urban life by studying the particular group of people on whom she centered her book examples here and here now goffman is being accused of felonylevel crimes and, by virtue of. Paul campos, alice goffmans implausible ethnography, chronicle of higher education august 21, 2015. Alice hoffmans novel is a beautiful union of history and myth in a world gone wrong. Alice goffman conducted some amazing ethnographic research, and her book is almost entirely true, not to mention quite important. Alice goffman s star fell almost as fast as it rose a few years back, as sociologists divided over her controversial book, on the run. Jun 25, 2015 at this point the debate about alice goffmans book on the run looks something like this. The object of dispute was goffmans debut book, on the run. I have documented thus far 15 problems in her book. Tangled in the web of that neighborhoods social relations, goffman wrote on the run through the lens of her own experience. I think he tries a bit too hard, but he does make three significant points. Alice goffman born 1982 is an american sociologist, urban ethnographer, and visiting. Law professors new book puts ethnography on trial the.
She teaches in the sociology department at the university of wisconsinmadison. Popular ethnography books meet your next favorite book. Fugitive life in an american city fieldwork encounters. Fugitive life in an american city has drawn more positive attention than almost any sociology book in recent years. Fugitive life in an american city, for which she received widespread praise as well as criticism for an indepth look at overpolicing, poverty, and incarceration experienced by young black men and their families in. Alice goffman wrote one of the most widely read sociology books in. Jun 18, 2015 the ethics of ethnography alice goffmans heralded book about innercity life has come under fire for inconsistencies and inaccuracies. If ethnographic theory is the hyperbola, anthropology is the ellipse. Many people have criticized alice goffmans ethnography on the run. Now, though, she was returning to madison for a fourday visit. Alice goffman is an american sociologist, urban ethnographer, and visiting assistant professor of sociology at pomona college. By turns on the run is heartbreaking and cleareyed, sad and entangled. Fugitive life in an american city was acclaimed in this magazine as a truly wonderful book that identifies the casualties of the war on drugs that extend beyond the prison wallsthe detail is incredible. Is the author to blameor does the fault lie with her field.
Alice goffmans heralded book on crime is disputed the new. The internet accused alice goffman of faking details in her. In the book, goffman describes driving a few nights, not only one. Pdf ethnography as methodology in alice goffmans on. Some of goffman s supporters maintained that her sixyear embed with innercity philadelphia youths pushed ethnography. The first set of criticisms i noticed were from people who claimed that she misrepresented black urban life by studying the particular group of people on whom she centered her book examples here and here.
A 34yearold untenured professor of sociology at the university of wisconsin, madison, goffman had just begun a year of leave at the institute for advanced study in princeton, which she hoped she might use to escape her critics and get back. Dear commons community, alice goffman is an assistant professor of sociology at the u. I personally dont find the case to be very interesting, or to speak to core issues of what ethnography is or should be. Mar 30, 2019 the recent controversy surrounding ethnography, sparked by the publication of alice goffmans book on the run, is the latest in a longstanding debate about the morals and ethics of ethnographic research. On the run is, by some distance, the most powerful work of ethnography that i have read for a very, very long time. For press inquiries, please contact james meader with a cc to isabella alimonti at picador. Fugitive life in an american city, sparked a fierce controversy, with some detractors claiming goffman had fabricated or misrepresented key elements of the critically acclaimed book. Fugitive life in an american city was published last year, alice goffman has achieved a measure of fame that is rarely visited on a young sociologist.
Conflict over sociologists narrative puts spotlight on. Jul 05, 2018 pachirats book starts with the premise that ten ethnographers he includes himself have arrived at a barn in new york states finger lakes district to stage a trial concerning sociologist alice goffmans 2014 ethnography, on the run. Jun 19, 2015 i think ive written and thrown away three separate posts on the alice goffman debate trying to find something to say that people will find interesting. Fugitive life in an american city, sparked a fierce controversy, with some detractors claiming goffman had fabricated or misrepresented key. Fugitive life in an american city, alice goffman is published by university of chicago press. The recent controversy surrounding ethnography, sparked by the publication of alice goffmans book on the run, is the latest in a longstanding. Apr 25, 2017 alice goffmans star fell almost as fast as it rose a few years back, as sociologists divided over her controversial book, on the run. Jul 15, 2015 near the end of her acclaimed book on the run. A comparison of statistics from the philadelphia police with the information provided by alice in her book, raises serious questions about the veracity of her work. Controversy over alice goffman leads pomona students to.
Alice goffmans implausible ethnography on the run reveals the flaws in how sociology is sometimes produced, evaluated, and rewarded. Jun 03, 2015 on the run is the story of sociologist alice goffmans six years of immersion in a struggling philadelphia neighborhood, in which she tells the stories of the routine stops, searches, raids. Aug 21, 2015 n ear the end of alice goffmans acclaimed 2014 book, on the run. Its author, alice goffman, a young sociologist, had an ethnography assignment for an. Roughly 40 years ago, many sociologists dismissed this genre of observational research as highfalutin journalism, says gary alan fine, a northwestern. The latest ethnography to cross my desk, alice goffman s on the run, has made a huge splash in the relatively small pond of academic books. Some considerations on the methods, dangers, and ethics of crackhouse research. Alice goffman and the future of ethnography huffpost. Alice goffman is an assistant professor of sociology at the u. Fugitive life in an american city, and allegations that it eschewed crucial disciplinary norms. The story of its genesis is almost as remarkable as the story at the heart of the book.
Douglas hartmann on ethnography in light of goffman kyle green on july 8, 2015 alice goffman s ethnographic foray into a black neighborhood in inner city philadelphia has attracted attention both inside and outside of academia. On the various controversies, see, for example, gideon lewiskraus, the changeling, new york times magazine january 17, 2016. Jan 01, 2014 a very engaging ethnography as a college student, the author moved to the inner city and spent her time hanging out with a group of young black men often on the run from the law. Pachirats book starts with the premise that ten ethnographers he includes himself have arrived at a barn in new york states finger lakes district to stage a trial concerning sociologist alice goffman s 2014 ethnography, on the run. Alice goffman is going to have a really hard time defending herself from her fiercest critics. The situation is a product of the united states skyrocketing incarceration ratesin the poor undereducated black neighborhood goffman studies, something like 10% of the young men are incarcerated.
By paul campos august 21, 2015 narayan mahon for the chronicle alice goffman and her book. Any such concerns are however quickly dispelled by alice goffmans extraordinary new book. On the run is, first and foremost, a remarkable feat of reporting. The best work of ethnography i have read in a very, very long time. Hanni will do anything to for lea, even something as dangerous as. On alice goffmans on the run and extrapolateable truth. At this point the debate about alice goffman s book on the run looks something like this. Lots has been written about alice goffman s on the run. Welcome, journalists june 19, 2015 rex i think ive written and thrown away three separate posts on the alice goffman debate trying to find something to say that people will find interesting. Fugitive life in an american city which is about the african american community of inner. Some of goffman s supporters maintained that her sixyear embed with innercity philadelphia youths pushed ethnography forward in important ways. By paul campos august 21, 2015 narayan mahon for the chronicle alice goffman and her book near the end of alice goffman s acclaimed 2014 book, on the run.
Urban sociology, ethnography, inequality, social interaction and social psychology, race and ethnicity, punishment book. Ethnography and the ethics of care the sociological. The level of detail in this book and goffmans ability to understand her. He thinks some ethnographers have an accuracy problem. Notes on alice goffman s on the run find, read and cite all the research you need on researchgate. Alice goffman born 1982 is an american sociologist, urban ethnographer, and visiting assistant professor of sociology at pomona college goffman is the author of on the run. Alice goffman s implausible ethnography on the run reveals the flaws in how sociology is sometimes produced, evaluated, and rewarded. Alice goffmans fieldwork in a struggling philadelphia neighborhood sheds harsh light on a justice system that creates suspects rather than citizens. Jun 07, 2015 screen shot of the new republic article. Jan 17, 2016 the trials of alice goffman her first book, on the run about the lives of young black men in west philadelphia has fueled a fight within sociology over who gets to speak for whom. At the new york times, alex kotlowitz raised some tentative ethical concerns in an otherwise positive. Alice goffman grew up in philadelphia and attended graduate school at princeton university.
As the world that we knew begins in berlin in the spring of 1941, hanni kohn is left with no choice but to get her 12yearold daughter, lea, out of germany if she has any hope of saving her life. The story of its genesis is almost as remarkable as. This blog is about why ethnographer erving goffman s observation of stigma are important not just to excons, but also to professors like me on foreign exchange programs. There are at least three reasons goffman s response is. Fugitive life in america is about young africanamerican boys and men on the run from the police in philadelphia. But as we are not trying to plumb an individual psyche for psychological motivation, but are rather trying to elucidate the relevant symbolic cultural meanings and practices, information garnered from those who do not like something is also relevant to understanding the cultural. Fugitive life in an american city, for which she received widespread praise as well as criticism for an indepth look at overpolicing, poverty, and incarceration experienced by young black men and their families in philadelphia. Like any ethnography, especially a first book, on the run has flaws that should be discussed.
577 745 566 1154 1518 381 1248 560 1622 1623 913 1463 527 1621 1153 655 147 1552 544 842 1044 1488 1032 836 1153 273 291 963 605 907 763 815 1286 1066 703 908 11 568 995 1035 612 82